Categories: Science & Technology

Apple vs. Samsung patent trial judge says lawyer William Lee must be on drugs

The judge in a patent trial involving Apple and Samsung has said iPhone maker’s lawyer William Lee must be on drugs if he thought she would accept his list of potential witnesses.

William Lee had named 22 people he wanted to rebut testimony given by Samsung’s choice of experts.

“Unless you’re smoking crack you know these witnesses aren’t going to be called” said Judge Lucy Koh.

William Lee replied: “Your honor, I’m not smoking crack. I can promise you that.”

The clash, reported by the Verge news site, took place close to the end of the trial after William Lee presented a 75-page document detailing the witnesses.

The judge in a patent trial involving Apple and Samsung has said iPhone maker's lawyer William Lee must be on drugs if he thought she would accept his list of potential witnessesThe judge in a patent trial involving Apple and Samsung has said iPhone maker's lawyer William Lee must be on drugs if he thought she would accept his list of potential witnesses
The judge in a patent trial involving Apple and Samsung has said iPhone maker's lawyer William Lee must be on drugs if he thought she would accept his list of potential witnesses

The judge had previously made it clear she wanted closing arguments to be presented next week. She has given each side a maximum of 25 hours to make its case.

Of that time Apple has less than four hours of witness testimony remaining on its clock, and William Lee said he honestly believed he could cover all the people he had named within that period.

The move could potentially have made it harder for Samsung’s legal team to prepare.

Samsung called on damages expert Michael Wagner shortly before the exchange, who said Apple had overestimated Samsung’s profit margins.

His evidence was intended to undermine the US firm’s claim that it was owed $2.5 billion in damages.

Under cross examination Michael Wagner acknowledged that his analysis had been based on data provided by Samsung as part of its response to Apple’s patent infringement accusations.

In addition to denying the allegations the South Korean firm is also pursuing its rival for royalty payments.

Judge Lucy Koh’s outburst is not the first time she has expressed anger at the two sides’ behavior in the case.

Earlier the judge chided Samsung’s lawyer John Quinn for approving a press release which publicized evidence she had ruled inadmissible in court.

She had also demanded each legal team write out their legal arguments after they wrangled over whether a witness should be allowed to present certain evidence, saying: “I don’t trust what any lawyer tells me in this courtroom. I want to see actual papers.”

Despite the potential large payouts involved in the case the firms’ share prices do not appear to have suffered.

Apple’s stock has closed at a record high of $636.34 after rising 6.9% since the start of the trial.

Samsung’s shares have gained 5.5% over the same period.

 

Nancy Clayson

Nancy is a young, full of life lady who joined the team shortly after the BelleNews site started to run. She is focused on bringing up to light all the latest news from the technology industry. In her opinion the hi-tech expresses the humanity intellectual level. Nancy is an active person; she enjoys sports and delights herself in doing gardening in her spare time, as well as reading, always searching for new topics for her articles.

Recent Posts

Happy New Year 2025: Sydney Welcomes New Year with Fireworks Display

Sydney has welcomed 2025 with a spectacular fireworks display - cheers erupted as the clock struck midnight…

2 days ago

Brad Pitt and Angelina Jolie Reach Divorce Settlement After 8 Years

Following an eight-year legal battle, Angelina Jolie and Brad Pitt have reached a divorce settlement,…

2 days ago

Former US President Jimmy Carter Dies at 100

Former President Jimmy Carter died on December 29 at the age of 100 after spending several…

2 days ago

Georgia: Outgoing President Salome Zourabichvili Refuses to Step Down After Mikheil Kavelashvili’s Inauguration

Georgia’s outgoing president Salome Zourabichvili refused to step down on December 29, saying she was…

5 days ago

Bald Eagle Officially Designated America’s National Bird After 250 Years

The bald eagle has been officially declared the national bird of the United States, after…

1 week ago

Kazakhstan Plane Crash: Dozens Survive Azerbaijan Airlines Plane Crash Near Aktau Airport

Dozens of passengers have survived a crash involving a plane carrying 69 people in Kazakhstan,…

1 week ago